Skip to content
IDAHO
CATTLE GUARDS

Materials

Concrete and precast cattle guards

A concrete or precast cattle guard trades handling convenience for mass: more weight to place, more equipment to get it there, and a structure that is hard to change afterwards. A steel grid is lighter, easier to set and easier to move. Both work; which one fits depends on the road, the ground and what can reach the crossing.

Steel, precast, cast-in-place

Steel gridPrecast concreteCast in place
Placing itTractor or skid steer, often enoughNeeds real lifting capacity on siteForms, pour, cure time
Time on siteShortestShort once it arrivesLongest - the concrete sets the schedule
Odd openingsStock widthsStock sizesFits what you have
Moving it laterPracticalPossible, expensiveNo
CleanoutRequiredRequiredRequired

General comparison, not product specifications. Dimensions, weights and ratings come from the manufacturer's documentation for the specific unit.

Gravel base compared with concrete abutmentsTwo sections side by side. On the left, a boxed guard set on compacted gravel with a shallower excavation. On the right, a guard set on poured concrete abutments with a deeper excavation and more room for cleanout.Gravel baseCOMPACTED GRAVELSHALLOWER DIGConcrete abutmentsPOURED ABUTMENTSDEEPER DIGSCHEMATIC - DEPTHS PER SITE AND SPEC
Which base you need depends on the ground and the load class, and it is settled at the site review - not from a catalogue.

Concrete base, concrete guard - not the same thing

Two different decisions get confused here. A concrete base means the guard - steel or otherwise - bears on poured abutments instead of compacted gravel. Aconcrete guard means the crossing structure itself is concrete. You can have a steel guard on concrete abutments, and that combination is what most highway-rated installs in Idaho look like.

What each base does to the cost

Whatever it is made of, the pit matters

A cattle guard works because an animal sees depth and declines. Fill the pit with silt and you have paved the crossing - the guard stops stopping stock, and it starts holding water, which is how frost lifts a frame or cracks a slab. Material choice does not change that.

Cleanout: a clear pit against a silted oneTwo sections. On the left, a clear pit under the rails with visible depth and drainage. On the right, the same guard with the pit filled with silt, so the rails sit on fill and stock can see a solid surface.ClearVISIBLE DEPTHDRAINS AND DRIESSilted upNO DEPTH TO SEEHOLDS WATER, LIFTS IN FROSTCLEANOUT ACCESS IS PART OF THE INSTALL, NOT AN EXTRA
A cattle guard works because stock can see depth. Once the pit fills, it is a bridge - which is why the install leaves a way to get the silt out.

Questions we get asked

Is a concrete cattle guard better than steel?
Neither is better across the board. Precast concrete units are heavy, need equipment to place and tend to be used where a very long service life and low maintenance matter. Steel grids are lighter to handle, easier to modify or move, and dominate ranch use. The right answer depends on the road, the ground and what equipment can get there.
What is the difference between concrete and precast?
Precast means the unit was cast off site and delivered cured, ready to set. Cast-in-place means it is formed and poured at the crossing. Precast is faster on site and more predictable; cast-in-place can fit an odd opening. Either way the concrete is one part of the structure - the running surface may still be steel rails.
Do concrete guards still need cleanout?
Yes. Anything that relies on visible depth to deter livestock relies on the pit staying open. Concrete does not silt up any slower than steel does.
Which is cheaper to install?
Usually the lighter option, because placement equipment and base work drive the install cost more than the unit does. A heavy precast unit on a road a truck cannot reach is the expensive version of a cheap idea.
Can you supply precast units?
We quote from what our supplier manufactures and can deliver into our service area. Tell us the opening and the load class and we will tell you honestly which options exist for it - including when the answer is a steel guard.
Get my free quote